poetry critical

online poetry workshop



simply put:
Xiada

after metamorphosis, butterflies eat
 1
only nectar
 2
 
 
 
 
 
 
change is not so sweet for some.
 3

16 Dec 05

Rated 10 (8.4) by 1 users.
Active (1): 10
Inactive (21): 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 7, 8, 8, 8, 9, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(18 more poems by this author)

(9 users consider this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

this is brilliant and so ... simple.
 — heat-her

thanks heat-her
 — Xiada

even though this is short, it says a hell of a lot to me... dont mind me stating the obvious>
 — starwars

What the other people said.
 — FangzOfFire

This is wonderful
 — redsky

thanks starwars, Fangz, and redsky
 — Xiada

awesome.

instead of 'eat' maybe you could consider using 'sip'?
an edit if i may:

after metamorphosis, butterflies
sip only nectar; change


is not so sweet for some.
 — varun

ummmmmmwhoa it says so much any more words and it would lose it
 — turtlepoet

pls explain why this should receive a higher number than 2.  please explain what i'm missing.  where is the content?  hear-her, what part is the "brilliant" part?
 — unknown

Normaly I don't like, or get the two or three line poems, but if they were with as much intellegence as this I would love em. Well done adn in so few words. Its border line brilliant.
 — Solstice

youre not explaining.  youre touting.
 — unknown

varun,

thanks for the suggestions. i originally had 'sip' but changed it to 'eat' because eat had a better feel to it/slightly jarring or unnatural. originally i had the first two lines:

butterflies sip
only nectar, after metamorphosis

but changed it to the current form so that 'change' and 'nectar' would stand out more. so i'm not sure i like the break you suggested. what do others think?
 — Xiada

turtle and solstice, thank you.
 — Xiada

Brilliantly done, the last line is perfect. Sweet and straight to the point, nice poem.
 — lonelygirl

well...nice thought, but actually they eat shit too. mebbe that wouldn't be so poetic...or would it?
 — unknown

perfect depression.
 — listen

it just doesn't seem very eloquent or thoughtful, as two/three line poems really have to be to achieve anything. i get it but the message seems so obvious and trite.
if i am missing anything, i would love to get an analysis and explanation from the author.
until then, i am giving this a well-deserved 5. it doesn't seem like enough thought was put into it.
 — ileviyou

ha ha you want an explanation when the poem is called 'simply put' l
 — unknown

bothersome.
 — unknown

true; thus, cool because it's true.
It has a clear metaphorical connection, but it's opposite. I don't think I've ever seen this done, at least not this good.
The title's OK, though.
 — delfinkay

change is not so sweet for some what?   some butterflies?
or you are switching to people in midpoem?
youre giving up on your metaphor after only one line?
you are not claiming that the _change_ is sweet for the butterfly,
only that the _food afterwards_ is sweet.  no sense.
this poem is like a half-eaten banana for some-
one piece, blatenly exposed, and not worth finishing.

how different is it from,
"some people get good stuff after they change.
too bad other people have a hard time."?
 — unknown

Simply put:

This foot

(in my mouth upon the negativity of anything I could say

bad about this.)
 — Opinion

simplicity is beautiful
 — inprogress

ileviyou- i'm glad you get the point, now think a little harder.

delfinkay- title suggestions?

unknown after delfinkay- 'some' is up for interpretation. use your imagination, friend.

opinion- thank you (?)

lonelygirl, listen, and inprogress- thank you
 — Xiada

I like this, but i do think that it could be better.
 — LostxItxAll

Ten. Favorite.
I believe nothing more must be said.

[Teo]
 — teo_omega11

I love this.
I think that sip would be better too, for accuracy's sake.

There is no need to explain or justify the analogy here, as it presents a perspective on change that is original and thought-provoking. It's incompleteness gives me space to think.

Perhaps you could look at my poem Butterflies?
 — smugzy

thanks for the consideration.
 — unknown

this is so beautiful and sadly true. <3
 — missmurder

simply put:
poems with colons in the title are way too magnetic. my mouse simply cannot stay away from them.
 — unknown

What is this stuff.
 — unknown

this is, well yes, simply put and well done

I wonder if "drink" might work better in place of "eat" but then, it might be too obious coupled with nectar.

last line (to make it less narrative in my head).  I am thinking of a different synonym for metamorhosis, rather than change, which is the obvious one: maybe transfigure, transform, something that is more active and suggestive of moving from one state to another.  Also, conversion, rebirth.  

transformation is not so
sweet for some

thank you, feel free to gloss over these suggestions
Maria
 — slancho

maria,
i used metomorphosis to describe the change from a scientific perspective, but thanks for your suggestions. i'm mulling over them for line 3.
 — Xiada

Your last line is fine. 'Transformation' is not cliche enough. Does one really talk about transformation not being as sweet?

Your poem is very neat.  Your title is a bit of weak though.
 — unknown

lovely
 — unknown

good changes ...
thank you
maria
 — slancho

wow. . . . so many things are not so simple, but then again so many things we choose to complicate. that is one of those simple truthes that nobody really knows how to put simply. . . . brilliant is really the perfect comment for this work of art.
 — LycanStorm

very nice.

10-faved.
: )
 — fractalcore

Stars are always high and let you look it up. But if you can shine you can become star. And the light comes from replica designer handbags because everyone can have it. 2012 Miu Miu brand offer new models which look more maturate and beautiful. Cheap replica designer handbags attracted the attention of many female friends, to meet their pursuit of luxury for them, while also saving a lot of expenses.
http://www.copyluxury.biz< br /> http://www.replicaha ndbags-uk.co.uk
http://www.replicawatches.c o
http://www.tagheuerwatche s.biz
 — hehandbags

0.232s