poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Angels in the Snow
PaulS

We stepped outside to winter's bite
 1
to white-washed fields, fresh and bright.
 2
through frosty breath she sneaked a peek,
 3
then smiled at me with cherry cheeks
 4
 
 
and asked
 5
 
 
grandpa, before we go,
 6
can we make angels in the snow?
 7
 
 
with a laugh
 8
 
 
we both fell back on drifted white
 9
flailing limbs with wild delight.
 10
I felt a warmth spread from within;
 11
for a moment I was five again.
 12
 
 
sometimes the way a child's voice rings
 13
can soften the hearts of hardened kings.
 14
who would think this children's game
 15
could drive the cold back whence it came?
 16
 
 
lessons learned are lessons earned
 17
the lesson here will not be spurned.
 18
any season is grand I know
 19
for making angels in the snow.
 20

2 Mar 08

Rated 10 (8.2) by 3 users.
Active (3):
Inactive (12): 1, 1, 7, 7, 7, 8, 8, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10

(define the words in this poem)
(50 more poems by this author)

(2 users consider this poem a favorite)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

I like it very much
 — nisetru

umm, to me "sneaked a peak" sounds kind of sexual...which I don't think you want.
 — unknown

How you find that phrase sexual in this context is beyond me.
 — PaulS

when i write for my grand-daughter i give her the present of a happy and complete poem and not a sermon about her grand-pa's ethics. you might, say, write her a poem where someone she knows is walking around doing something surprising -- kind of the way you'd tell her a bed time story over several days.

it's not that you've done something odd -- almost everyone here thinks poetry is about advertising their virtues and wants -- it's just that it seems such a wasted thing, that you're a poet and you can't give your grand-daughter a real literature of her own.
 — joey

Thanks joey--believe it or not I always find something useful in your crits.
 — PaulS

i think this is very endearing.
i love the playful, light verse and the images of children in the snow.

when i read line 4, i was stopped by 'with a' and thought it might sound smoother if you pluralized cheeks.  i also read 'cherry cheek' at first, which was kind of cute in the cold.
If you punctuate after line 11, then you could remove the stubborn "and" that harshes line 12.
L16, might need a 'from' before 'whence'.

just a few small things that i stumbled on,
still, very nice nostalgic poem,
thanks paul.
=-)
 — jenakajoffer

Thanks for the advice jen---I made some of the suggested changes.
 — PaulS

very nice paul
very smooth =-)
jen-
 — unknown

DONT LIKE GRANDPA POEMS
 — OKcomputer

this is much nicer without that preface now.

OKcomputer, not all grandpas are good, i suppose.
: )
 — fractalcore

Thanks fractalcore.  I should have left the preface off in the first place.
 — PaulS

This is wonderful!  You've captured the spirit of grandparenting quite well!  Even the rhyme is working.  I feel the chill, I have snow down the back of my neck.

You are my kind of grandpa!  
 — Isabelle5

This is a very perfect example of poetry at it's finest.  No forced rhyme, which I'm thanking god for, haha. ;D

And Joey, this doesn't seem to be him bragging about a grandfather's, but how much he enjoys her company and how she let him see that perhaps being a bitter old man isn't too fun.  Take from his example and stop being a bitter old mean buttface loserheadguy.
 — Aziel

*bragging about a grandfather's ethics
 — Aziel

Thank you, Aziel--for the comment and taking the time to read it.
 — PaulS

wow. i cant say that your rhyme scheme really clicks with me but the way that you wrote it... just the way that you describe it makes me miss my grandfather (i didnt know him well).
i like this. thanks for the comment by the way, i appreciate it.
 — brokenarrows

Paul, write me when you have a chance, catch me up on this poem, etc.
 — Isabelle5

Thanks for the comment brokenarrows, much appreciated.  Isabelle, thanks for the revisit.
 — PaulS

Simple and hallmark-esque, but nice.
 — CryptApoidea

"Catch instants, every second a heart beat."   L.Ferlinghetti... Paul as usual your simple talent with words and thought amaze me... Poet   j.g. smiles
 — goeszon

a small short coming... although a year or more ago still you rate a 10
 — goeszon

in between your words , i stumble upon thoughts only a poet could bring out in time...  
 — ambiguos

Very well written, a beautiful "feel good" poem.
 — Simpa23

CryptApoidea, goeszon, ambiguos and Simpa23---thank you all for your kind comments :)
 — PaulS

it shouldve ended at 12 after that the poem degenerates into forced rhyme and a moral that is completely unnecessary
line 11 thats what happens to some 5 yearolds who drank too much juice before going outside and not wanting to go through all the trouble of taking all their riggin off
 — chuckle_s

thanks for reading chuckle_s, sorry you didn't like it.  I'm not sure what you mean by forced rhymes--i could be wrong, but I don't see any.
 — PaulS

forced rhymes:

hardened kings -- whenever the poem suddenly veers away from its focus - in this case a very simple scene, a very common memory for manymany people - and goes into something out of left field for the sake of rhyme only, i call that forced rhyme. hardened kings? come on now, that is out of left field.

children's game -- dude, i'm from central ontario my entire life, i know about snow angels, and it's not 'a game'. it's just some stupid thing that's fun to do in the snow. i'm calling this forced rhyme.

whence it came -- whence? i'm not so sure this word flies in the unforced-rhyme-due-to-naturally-occurring-syntax airspace. 'yo, Lou, wanna put them boxes whence they came?'

19/20 any season is grand i know for making angels in the snow -- this is an inversion. typical form of forced rhyme.

you know i don't much care one way or the other, i just have to call em as i see em, sometimes. i really liked the poem up to 12, but i think it went too far and dug a tunnel in a huge hill and then the tunnel collapsed and the poor thing suffocated,  
 — chuckle_s

I don't find it very original. The ending (13-20) has the meaning of the poem but it breaks the tempo of the poem and is too literal. I'm not a fan of the rhyming style, it's like you wright as if you learned it in the 5-year olds class. Maybe you wanted to do a pantoum?
 — unknown

Nice poem of rhyming couplets, which help with the feel of this happy, cherished moment with one's grandchild
 — JohnW

Recent Best (expand)
    0.307s