poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Before the Sunsets
trochee

Find me somewhere
 1
between precise moments
 2
in a cellar with ancient light
 3
fading above my notes.
 4
 
 
Search me in the old crowds;
 5
left alone shoes, derelict umbrellas,
 6
a wrinkled photograph may be
 7
resting next to a telephone booth.
 8
 
 
In an old-fashioned bistro
 9
sipping life in allayed gulps
 10
hovering over genial thoughts
 11
look for my signs
 12
before the sunsets
 13
and the vulgar secrets
 14
of strangers
 15
scribbled on the pews.
 16
 
 
I have dropped the keys
 17
to be lost again.
 18

29 Dec 08

Rated 8.7 (8.7) by 3 users.
Active (3): 8, 8, 10
Inactive (0):

(define the words in this poem)
(68 more poems by this author)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

Search me in the old crowds; ?
 — unknown

genital thoughts
dont drop the soap
 — chuckle_s

unknown come again.

Chuckie you are getting predictable mate
 — trochee

The only question I have is do you want sun sets, as in the verb sets or sunsets, the noun?  If it is the verb, you might need to add 'are' in line 16.

I love the search, looking here and there, an old photo found on the ground by a phone booth, which is rare enough to find these days.  

This is good, creative and gives the reader good imagery to work with.
 — Isabelle5

no, 'are' would not be 'necessary' in either case.
 — unknown

Yes, it would.  If it were 'sun sets,' you need are or it would be incomplete.  Try reading it that way, you'll see.  If sets is a verb, then 'and' is connecting two verbs, you have to have 'are scribbled.'

How can anyone write poetry effectively if they don't know how their language works?  
 — Isabelle5

you are wrong; 'are' would not be 'necessary' in either case.

In an old-fashioned bistro
sipping life in allayed gulps
hovering over genial thoughts  
look for my signs  
before the sun sets  
and the vulgar secrets  
of strangers  
scribbled on the pews.

in the case of sun sets as verb, the parse would indicate that the command is as follows:

look for my signs
before the sun sets
and (meaning 'also look for') the vulgar secrets
of strangers
scribbled on the pews.

this is clear to me when i read it.

"How can anyone write poetry effectively if they don't know how their language works?" - indeed.
 — unknown

I don't agree but you're welcome to your thoughts on it.
 — Isabelle5

I think we are simply reading this differently.  I understand what you see and I understand what I see.  That's the fun part of poetry, many readers can see it differently and still be correct.
 — Isabelle5

thanks guys
but just to clear the air, its not a verb.
 — trochee

before sunsets
there are many visions to capture
and i wonder
if i will find your secrets
and scribbles
while the light casts
no shadow
or if i should search for them
after sunrise.

nice poem,
many 'the's i see in the 3rd stanza, particularly L13, 14, 16--any way to rid one or two?
you ol' romantic, you.
 — jenakajoffer

Very effective and well written.
 — PaulS

0.426s