poetry critical

online poetry workshop



Red Roses, No Encore
Isabelle5

I learned to read your body when you spoke -
 1
more eloquent than words -
 2
 
 
when Vodka tangled up your tongue,
 3
when whiskey made you mean,
 4
your body language warned me
 5
with the truth.
 6
 
 
A drunken kiss attempted might not
 7
have landed upon a proffered cheek
 8
but there was always success for your fist,
 9
which never failed to make contact
 10
when your booze-fueled anger burned.
 11
 
 
I read a book which clearly said
 12
“One cannot have a relationship
 13
with a bottle,” but yes, oh yes, I did.
 14
 
 
You were the bottle come to life,
 15
a stuporous dancer on a brilliant,
 16
back-lit stage, pretending
 17
to be a husband,
 18
pretending to be whole,
 19
 
 
while I was the dumbfounded
 20
audience of one, applauding
 21
with blistered hands,
 22
 
 
fooling no one but the dead-eyed woman
 23
who smiled at me with bleeding lips
 24
from her cracked and sorrowed mirror.
 25

10 Feb 09

Rated 8.5 (8.5) by 2 users.
Active (2): 8, 9
Inactive (0):

(define the words in this poem)
(237 more poems by this author)



Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha

Comments:

Very true and very effectively written.  The metaphor is equally as impressive throughout.  
 — unknown

Let's have a closer look at L2.  In my opinion, "much more eloquent than any words" has a clunk to it; it seems weighed down by too many words."  My suggestion would be:  "more eloquently (Make the adjective an adverb.) than words.  Food 4 thought.  
 — unknown

Yes, I see that.  I made a small change, not happy with eloquently but I like your having pointed out that line.  
 — Isabelle5

Good!  Better!  
 — unknown

i love abuse, personally.
 — unknown

Well, thank you for that helpful insight into your life but how does that help me write this poem better?
 — Isabelle5

well 7-8 are clunky..."attempted" and "might not" strung together? well, the former informs the latter does it not...? and then "proffered" is just too much language really, too 19th century i think.

"with the truth" is jarring. but i can't really distinguish it from the previous line, which is to say, they don't jive. and to me, the end note falls short of the promise the second strophe inititally set-up. "vodka" and "whiskey" being tangible. the "tangled" tongue being very much real for me.

"stuporous"-- yes, fitting. but maybe a tad over-analytical.

"applauding...." and from there it is nicely ended.

yay! a poem with promise.
 — DeformedLion

THROW UP
 — unknown

Strong opening. Brilliant title. Stanzas 2, 4, and 5 are most effective to my reading. I especially like L15, dynamic metaphor and deceptively true. I might drop "brilliant" out of it.
 — NicMichaels

BTW it ain't easy to use roses in a fresh way unless you have a vase, but you did that, in the title. Bravo.
 — NicMichaels

0.404s